PROJECT MANAGEMENT 101 AT WESTON & SAMPSON
MODULE 1 · WEEK 2
Score the Go/No-Go
The Town of Millbrook advertised RFP 26-014 on 8 September 2026. Proposals are due 29 September at 2:00 P.M., which is 21 days.
What does Millbrook score on the Go/No-Go form, and does the recommendation proceed?
What is given
- The form
- 15 questions. Q1 and Q2 are gates. Q3 through Q13 carry 100 points.
- Section A
- Qualification minimums. Q1, Q2, Q3.
- Section B
- Strategic Fit and Positioning. Q4 through Q10. 60 points.
- Section C
- Profitability and Resources. Q11. 10 points.
- Section D
- Operational Readiness. Q12, Q13, Q14. 20 points.
- The line
- 70 points or higher and the recommendation proceeds to final review.
- Q14
- Worth 5 points and available only when the total falls below 70.
Points are exact. Every passage the form needs is quoted on this page.
Step 1Section A, the gates and the license question
Written Lesson, Sections 1.2.3 and 1.2.4.1
Q1 asks whether our firm meets the minimum and comparative evaluation criteria. The solicitation states both.
The Proposer must hold a current Certificate of Authorization from the Florida Board of Professional Engineers under Section 471.023, Florida Statutes, and the individual who will serve as Engineer of Record must hold a current Florida Professional Engineer license. Evidence of both must be included in TAB 1.
The Proposer, or a named subconsultant on the Proposer's team, must demonstrate completion within the past ten (10) years of at least one stormwater model calibrated to observed tailwater and storm event data that supported a permitted drainage design in a coastal municipality. Evidence must be included in TAB 2.
Any proposal that does not meet the minimum qualifications as stated above will be rejected. The criteria below are not necessarily listed in order of importance.
| Criteria | Maximum points |
|---|---|
| Qualifications and Experience of Firm and Sub-Firms | 20 |
| Qualifications and Experience of Person(s) Assigned to the Project | 20 |
| Project Understanding and Approach | 30 |
| Schedule for Completion | 15 |
| Minority Business Qualification | 5 |
| Specified Supplement Information | 10 |
| Max points | 100 |
Pursuant to Section 287.055, Florida Statutes, price is not a criterion in the ranking of firms. The Town will negotiate a scope and a fee with the highest ranked firm following ranking.
Weston & Sampson holds a current Florida Certificate of Authorization, and the proposed Engineer of Record holds a current Florida PE license.
Our firm has not produced a calibrated tailwater model in a coastal municipality in the past ten years. The specialty stormwater subconsultant on the team has produced four, and the solicitation allows a named subconsultant to satisfy the requirement. That subconsultant work is the $40,000 of other direct costs in the fee build.
Q2 asks whether our firm can commit the time and attention. Twenty-one days is a short window, and Marketing cannot guarantee support on less than two weeks of lead time, so the Go decision has to land inside the first week. The Technical Lead has confirmed capacity.
| Question | Points |
|---|---|
| Q1. We meet all the minimum and comparative evaluation criteria | Gate |
| Q2. We can commit the time and attention to complete the proposal within the agreed upon schedule and be responsive throughout the process | Gate |
| Q3. We are licensed for all required services, corporately and individually | 10 |
A No on Q1 or Q2 is an automatic No-Go and ends the pursuit whatever the total.
Both gates clear. How many points does Section A score?
Two tries. After the second the page shows the worked solution and carries the correct value forward.
Q1 clears, because the subconsultant satisfies the calibrated model minimum and the solicitation permits it. Q2 clears, because the Technical Lead confirmed capacity inside the 21 day window. Neither gate carries points.
Q3 is Yes. Our firm holds the Certificate of Authorization and the Engineer of Record holds a Florida PE license.
Section A = 10 points
Step 2Section B, strategic fit and positioning
Written Lesson, Sections 1.2.4.2, 1.2.5 and 1.2.6
Seven questions, 60 points. Every answer needs a basis. Confirmed means the solicitation, client knowledge, firm records or a named source supports it. Inferred means a reasonable conclusion from what the team already holds. Unknown means the team does not have it yet, and an Unknown cannot support a Yes.
In 2025, the Town of Millbrook completed with consultant Harlow Reed Engineering, Inc. the Multi-Basin Assessment and Basin 4 Project Implementation Plan (MB-B4 PIP).
The Town has not previously retained a firm other than Harlow Reed Engineering, Inc. for neighborhood infrastructure planning. The Town seeks a CONSULTANT capable of performing an independent evaluation of alternatives rather than confirming a prior recommendation.
This RFP has been developed to solicit information from consulting engineering firms (or teams of firms) proven to be qualified and experienced in civil, roadway, engineering, water and sewer utilities, stormwater management, and construction supervision. As the project area has been and will be impacted by tropical weather events, responding firms should integrate best resiliency practices into all design elements.
The Project has been initiated by the Millbrook Community Redevelopment Agency and the Town of Millbrook to renew critical infrastructure of the subject neighborhood and to contract with the CONSULTANT to develop and implement infrastructure renewal in the Cypress Landing East neighborhood.
CONSULTANT shall begin with a concept layout from the 2024 Basin Assessments and adapt as appropriate for implementation. Authorization for work will proceed on a phase-by-phase basis.
| Question | What our firm holds |
|---|---|
| Q4. Capture plan in place | Yes. A capture plan for Sabal County municipal utilities was approved in March 2026. |
| Q5. Heard about it before release | Yes. The Cypress Landing East Neighborhood Plan and the 2024 Basin Assessments have been public for months. |
| Q6. Relationship with the client | No. Millbrook has never retained our firm. |
| Q7. We helped write the RFP | No. Nothing in the document came from us. |
| Q8. Targeted for ongoing work | Yes. Millbrook is a named target account. |
| Q9. Fits a firm initiative | Yes. Treatment, resiliency and energy, and Southeast growth. |
| Q10. We can distinguish ourselves | Yes. The Town asks for an independent evaluation rather than confirmation of a prior recommendation. |
Tick every question our firm can answer Yes with evidence. The total fills in below.
How many of the 60 points does Section B score?
Two tries. After the second the page shows the worked solution and carries the correct value forward.
Yes on Q4, Q5, Q8, Q9 and Q10. No on Q6, because Millbrook is a new client and the Background says so. No on Q7, because our firm had no hand in the document.
10 + 10 + 10 + 10 + 5 = 45 of 60
A No on Q6 or Q7 costs points and stops nothing. Only Q1 and Q2 stop a pursuit.
Step 3Sections C and D, and the total
Written Lesson, Sections 1.2.4.2 and 1.2.4.3
Section C asks one question about profitability. Section D asks about our firm's readiness to deliver.
Location of firm(s) and team members in proximity to Millbrook.
Provide an estimated level of effort for each phase of the Scope of Work, expressed in staff-hours by labor classification, and identify which tasks the proposer intends to perform through a subconsultant or an outside laboratory. Do not include hourly rates, unit costs, or fees. Pursuant to Section 287.055, Florida Statutes, price is not a criterion in the ranking of firms, and any submittal containing a fee will be returned for correction.
Demonstrate experience and qualifications of the firm on related projects, as well as any sub-firms, including MBE/WBE and DBE firms, on the project team. Experience should detail relevant experience in residential neighborhood infrastructure renewal and in commercial road areas.
Demonstrate specific knowledge of the firm's past project experiences that would include relationships with regulatory agencies, particularly FDOT, FDEP, and the water management district.
The Town has established a Disadvantaged Business Enterprise participation goal of twelve percent (12%) of the total contract value for this Project.
Provide a Team organization chart and identify where the project will be managed from (office locations) and where the various work components will be done (office locations).
Identify the individual who will perform the stormwater modeling, whether that individual is an employee of the prime or of a subconsultant, and the number of calibrated tailwater models that individual has personally produced.
| Question | What our firm holds |
|---|---|
| Q11. The proposed fee allows us to run the project profitably · 10 points | Yes. The bottom-up estimate builds to $250,000 including the $40,000 subconsultant scope, and that clears the target ELM. |
| Q12. Experience on similar projects in the region · 10 points | Yes. Four neighborhood utility renewals in Florida in the past five years, with performance data for each. |
| Q13. Staff in the area · 5 points | Yes. The Tampa office is 90 minutes from Millbrook and holds the project team. |
| Q14. We should submit even if the score is lower than 70 · 5 points | Available only below 70. |
Sections C and D together score 25 of their 30 points, because Q14 is not available at or above 70.
What is the total score on the form?
Two tries. After the second the page shows the worked solution and carries the correct value forward.
Add the four sections.
10 + 45 + 10 + 15 = 80 points
Eighty is at or above the 70 line, so the recommendation proceeds to final review and Q14 never applies. Eighty is also the ceiling for a new client, because Q6 and Q7 are unavailable by definition.
The recommendation
Eighty points against a 70 point line. The recommendation proceeds to final review, and the pursuit information goes into the opportunity record.
The two gates did the real work. Our firm cleared the calibrated model minimum only through a named subconsultant, and that decision put $40,000 of other direct costs into the fee before anyone wrote a word of the proposal.
The two automatic No-Go questions decide whether our firm may pursue the work. The scored questions describe how well our firm is positioned to win.
A new client cannot score above 80 on this form. Knowing the ceiling is what makes 80 a strong result rather than a mediocre one.